Chapter 219: Confrontation
Now Shu Keyuan's appearance in court has become the focus. After hearing Nangong Jinyan's words, Shu Keyuan was stunned for a moment, then pointed directly at He Tianyi and said, "It was him, he kidnapped me, he is the real murderer!"
As soon as this sentence came out, the audience was in an uproar. No one expected that Shu Keyuan's attitude was so firm. When Shu Keyuan pointed at He Tianyi, Nangong Jinyan looked at Lawyer Ye and asked, "Lawyer Ye, you heard it clearly.
Is it? My witness, the victim, personally accused He Tianyi of being the murderer. Is this also my client who coerced He Tianyi to frame him? That's really ridiculous. Should I tell you a joke?"
As soon as Nangong Jinyan said something, the audience couldn't help but smile. Lawyer Ye was angry and immediately thought of the judge's application: "Judge, I have a few words to ask this witness, please approve it."
The judge nodded.
After receiving the reply, Lawyer Ye walked to Shu Keyuan and asked in a questioning tone: "Miss Shu, I am curious. You have been kidnapped for so long and Li Zhengde has been detained for so long. Why didn't you come out to prove that it was my commission.
What a person did? Just come out to testify at this time? Are you threatened by someone, or sold by someone to perjure me and falsely accused me of the client? Please look in my eyes and answer me!”
"I protest!" As soon as Lawyer Ye's words came out, Nangong Jinyan quickly protested, "Judge, he is threatening and intimidating my witness. My witness has the right not to answer this question!"
"Judge, this is just me collecting evidence and seeking truth from it. This is very important for the investigation of the case!" Lawyer Ye immediately followed.
"Protest is invalid!" This sentence was said to Nangong Jinyan, and then reminded Lawyer Ye, "But the defendant's defense lawyer should also pay attention to your tone and wording."
"Yes." Lawyer Ye nodded, then looked at Shu Keyuan and said, "Please answer my question just now."
Shu Keyuan let out a breath, but her expression was so calm and calm, without a trace of panic, and she slowly explained: "Since I was kidnapped and rescued, I have been in the hospital. My consciousness has not been very clear.
After I was discharged from the hospital, I learned that He Tianyi had been sued in court, so I found lawyer Nangong to testify. If you don’t believe it, you can check my medical records."
Shu Keyuan said it very naturally, and there was no trace of lying. Nangong Jinyan said: "In order to convince Lawyer Ye and the defendant, I went to the hospital to copy the medical record of my witness."
As he said that, Nangong Jinyan took out a medical record in his hand, and then added: "If these still cannot convince you, I have also found her attending hospital. If I need it, I can also invite them to you.
Confrontation.”
"No need!" said Lawyer Ye, "But even if Shu Keyuan's medical record is true, so what? This cannot completely get rid of the suspicion of being bribed to make fake certificates. Shu Keyuan is a soldier and has worked as a subordinate of Nangong Ming and Leng Qing.
Bing, this is no secret. This time I came to T City and lived in your house. In fact, she has a close relationship with your Nangong family. It is reasonable for you to collude with each other!"
"It's ridiculous!" After hearing the comments from Lawyer Ye, Nangong Jinyan retorted in public, "Lawyer Ye, please pay attention to it. I am the lawyer invited by Li Zhengde. This is different from whether I am from the Nangong family. Miss Shu
He is the victim of this incident. Even if she really has a close relationship with us, would she help the real murderer who hurt her to frame an innocent person? To give a simple example, Lawyer Ye, you were kidnapped, and your father
It just so happens that he is a friend of the kidnapper. For the sake of your father, you will not hesitate to appear in court to commit perjury to frame an innocent person in order to get rid of the kidnapper. Even if you are willing, your mother will not be willing, right?"
"you!"
"I'm just an example!" Nangong Jinyan said sternly, and then said to the judge, "Judge, I have already said it very clearly just now. In addition, my witness, that is, the victim, before coming to T City.
I don't know He Tianyi at all. It's just a conflict of interest caused by this mission. The same is true for my client. She has no need to risk breaking the law and commit perjury, so my witness's testimony is completely credible.
of!"
"I protest!" Before Nangong Jinyan finished speaking, Lawyer Ye spoke again, "Even if they can rule out the suspicion of collusion to tamper with testimony, it cannot rule out the possibility that she was coerced and bribed!"
"I was not coerced. Everything I said here today is true!" Shu Keyuan corrected immediately.
"It is hard to convince yourself. Since you prove that my client is the murderer, what evidence can you prove your words? The little girl, if you say it without any evidence, you will be in jail even if you do perjury!"
"I protest! He threatened my witness again, Lord Judge, if one person testified in court and said that there was no basis for this statement, then what else would he need to do? My witness was kidnapped and his life was hanging on the line except her
What else can you use to prove what you see? I dare ask Lawyer Ye, if you are kidnapped, there are only two people in the scene, and the kidnappers were arrested afterwards. If you appear in court to identify whether you are not only bringing your mouth with you
Have a reality show video? If there is really that video, what do you need to do as a witness?"
"Lawyer Nangong, please don't always use me as an example!"
"This is a need for argumentation!" Lawyer Nangong's tone was not allowed to be argued, and then immediately asked, "And Lawyer Ye, you just said that my witness was coerced and bribed by us, so please also ask us to coerced and bribed the witnesses.
If you can't produce the evidence, I will think that you are talking nonsense and slandering people here. If you can't produce evidence to prove that you are not a witness who is falsely accusing me, don't testify here that my witness is doing
Perjury and falsely accus your client!"
"Judge, my witness has made it clear just now, and the lawyer on the other side cannot provide any evidence to prove that my witness is lying, but my witness's testimony is completely credible. Also, my witness has just been
He had been kidnapped and had just recovered from a serious illness. He had just been discharged from the hospital. He asked her to leave the court and rest now, otherwise her body would really not be able to bear it!" Nangong Jinyan did not give Lawyer Ye a chance to breathe and refute, and pressed him step by step.
After hearing this request, the judge asked Lawyer Ye: "What other questions does the defendant have to ask the witness?"
Lawyer Ye does have some questions to ask, such as asking him to explain the details at that time, and the specific details that prove that He Tianyi was a kidnapper, but he knew that after he asked these, he would have a sudden incident by Nangong Jinyan.
There was also a reason for Shu Keyuan to reject her health. After considering that, Lawyer Ye still shook her head: "No for the time being."
"Okay, now the witness can temporarily withdraw from court." The judge issued an order.
Shu Keyuan retreated to the court first and took advantage of the victory to pursue. Nangong Jinyan did not give the other party a chance to breathe, and immediately said: "If you think I only have someone to testify this time, then you are wrong."
Then Nangong Jinyan took the information collected by Li Mingze from his assistant and first showed it to everyone: "Look, this is the record of all accounts of He Tianyi since he arrived in City T.
People with a little economic mind will see the clues of these accounts. This is what He Tianyi is trying hard to conceal, but the net of heaven is vast and not leaked, and these things have been dug out. Of course, you can also say this
It was coerced by my client, but this was inconsistent with He Tianyi's confession. He, He Tianyi, told the police before that he accidentally discovered the evidence of my client's crime, but he had not handed over it for a long time.
He did not participate at all, but these ironclad evidence proved that he had indeed participated. So, Mr. He, why did you hide your crime at that time?"
The words that Nangong Jinyan asked were unambiguous and aggressive, which made He Tianyi and Lawyer Ye speechless for a moment. Seeing this, Lawyer Ye hurriedly said: "Judge, I ask to take a look at the evidence provided by the other party!"
The judge nodded, Lawyer Ye took it over, looked carefully, his face changed slightly, and Nangong Jinyan asked: "Lawyer Ye, did you see something wrong? Do you still think this is forged?"
Lawyer Ye was stunned for a moment and looked at Nangong Jinyan and retorted: "This information is indeed true, but it can only mean that 'He Tianyi' has participated, and will this 'He Tianyi' be me.
What about the parties involved? In what lawyer Nangong said just now, my client kidnapped Shu Keyuan to frame your client, and this thing is very likely that your client used these things to frame my client.
My client's boss, it's not difficult to do this. Lawyer Nangong just mentioned the matter of my client's previous record. I have to mention here that your client has been involved in gang crimes for six years.
, it's even more a trick for these things."
Lawyer Ye said this slowly. As soon as he said something, Nangong family and Li Mingze were both excited and excited, and they really had the urge to go up.
"According to your opinion, if this evidence of crime is really what my client wants to frame He Tianyi, then when did he do this? If it was done before, why didn't he hand over it when he was arrested? Why didn't he hand it over when he was arrested?
Have to wait until now? If you only do it after entering prison, do you think the police are just eating a waste? Huh?" Nangong Jinyan said this with a strong tone, and then said to the judge, "Judge, everyone's evidence
All the physical evidence is there, and the defendant He Tianyi is suspected of being involved in a gang transaction, and the kidnapping is unresolvable!"
Chapter completed!