During the trial, Shangguanwen explained the mentality of the deceased's mentality of striking the car, but lacked the courage to striking the car. The man crossed the road not once or twice. On the same section of the road, he could see a man crossing the road at least twice every day. A colleague persuaded the man, but the man replied that if he was hit, he would be considered unlucky.

After the first trial, the judge hoped that the case would be settled. The man had a mistake first, which is certain. The prosecutor could not prove the driver's mistake from the process, but could only prove that the driver had made a mistake from the result. The judge mediated and asked the driver to compensate the deceased for a certain amount of money and settled the case.

Shangguan Wen asked Bai Su's meaning, and Bai Su told Shangguan Wen that Lao Li had driven himself for 30 years and had nothing happened. He could not ruin his reputation by a bastard. So Shangguan Wen not only refused to accept mediation, but also prosecuted the deceased's family to compensate for the vehicle losses.

The case was held four times in the end, and Shangguan Wen won the case. Not only was the driver not guilty, but the family of the deceased had to compensate 150,000 yuan for vehicle damage. What's more, more than 60 days later, Shangguan Wen applied for compulsory execution and did not accept postponed mediation. The court seized and auctioned the deceased's property with a mortgage of 27 years in accordance with the law.

It can be seen that Shangguan Wen is very loyal to Bai Su. He can serve as the head of the department and a senior manager who is directly under the leadership of the president. Loyalty is a must-have quality. That little money is not money for Bai Su. Her purpose is to protect her drivers, and even to make a living. After all, Shangguan Wen’s aggressive pursuit does not conform to the mainstream moral values ​​of society and is very promising and unkind.

Cao Yun did not understand Shangguan Wen through this case, but instead had a better understanding of Bai Su. Without knowing Shangguan Wen, the director of the legal department of the Universe Group, his strength was definitely not to be said. However, he had not many trials, and it was hard to say how much strength he could exert during the trial. Unfortunately, the information did not explain the reason why Shangguan Wen participated in Xu's father's case, and Cao Yun was even more curious about this.

Looking at the information about Xu's father's case, it is basically the same as the police, and the prosecutor's understanding is basically the same. However, there are too many explanations of Xu's father and the landlady.

The day of the incident was the second night of the first cold wave that began to hit last year. Wang Xia died from 10:50 to 11:00. Xu's father said that after he left the Wang family's fish soup at 10:30 that night, he went to wait and check out the landlady. He found that the landlady came home from the mahjong hall opposite his home at 11:50. If the evidence is true, it can prove that Xu's father was not the murderer.

The landlady is listed on the list of witnesses, and also includes the owner of the mahjong hall and the landlady's friend.

Among the witnesses, there is a man who is very strange to Cao Yun. His name is Okazaki, who is the owner of a fish soup restaurant near Wang Family Fish Soup. It is not very close. The two stores are more than 300 meters in a straight line. Okazaki, like Xu's father, is a second-hand man. It is particularly noted that they are inmates, and the two are only two months apart when they are released from prison for the second time.

Is Okazaki the murderer?

...

The quality of the food has dropped significantly, no longer a buffet or ordering. It is a boxed meal. Two meat and one vegetable, and the taste has also dropped by a certain level.

After dinner, I rested for a night, and after breakfast, the first trial of Xu's father's case began.

Not only Cao Yun, but also six or seven young lawyers were heard, all of whom were slightly older than Cao Yun and were just or about to handle the case independently. First, they also followed the exposure rate and accumulated experience. At the same time, they also showed that the Lieyan Court did not take the police seriously at least in this trial. In addition, they also explained the reasons for the decline in the quality of the food. There were too many people, and most of them were irrelevant people. For example, the jury was eleven people who did not need to exist. Do you agree that you are not guilty and the real court would be acquitted?

Judge No. 1: "Considering the police's position, this trial may end at any time. Let me also explain to the police that you must want to catch us. Even if you have clues, please wait until the case is over before you interrupt the trial. Because we are calling for an injustice for someone who was wronged by you and sentenced to death."

Judge No. 1: "The trial begins."

Sima Luo began to read the accusation letter, Cao Yun looked at the defense seat, Guo Xiaotian and Shangguan Wen were all listed, and Xu Na was among them. Little girl, why are you joining in the fun?

After Sima Luo finished reading, Guo Xiaotian stood up first: "My name is Guo Xiaotian, and he is a lawyer at Galaxy Law Firm. Let me explain here that I did not volunteer to go to the Lieyan Court. Since I have come, I will definitely do my best. Let me get back to the point. First of all, I have questions about a detail that the prosecution said. The prosecution said that the couple met Xu's father near Wangjia Fish Soup at about 11 o'clock on the evening of the crime. Can they invite them to attend?"

Judge No. 1 said: "Couple men can attend, couples and girls are already someone else's wife, and they are abroad."

So the couple man sat in the witness stand, and during the waiter No. 1 took the camera and asked Cao Yun: "Lawyer Cao, what do you think is the reason for Lawyer Guo's actions?"

Cao Yun was stunned when he looked at the camera, and then replied: "It was confirmed that Xu's father was still near Wangjia Fish Soup at around 11 o'clock. One was a couple and the other was a shop owner across the street. The defense must first cancel the testimony of these two groups before he could continue to defend."

"What does it mean to kill?"

Cao Yun said: "Let the testimony be doubtful, and testimony with doubts will not be adopted."

"Thank you, Lawyer Cao."

Waiter No. 1 then visited another young lawyer who was hearing the trial.

Cao Yun once doubted whether the Flame Court had received permission from the police and became more and more arrogant.

Couple male enters the witness stand.

Guo Xiaotian was very calm and walked to the witness stand and asked, "Witness, should you describe your appearance to the police first, or should the police first recognize the photos?"

The couple man replied: "The police collected witnesses. I passed the section of the road before and after the incident, so I went to the police station. The police handed me the photo of the suspect and asked if it was him. My ex-girlfriend and I didn't answer immediately, saying that the person was wearing a raincoat. The police changed the raincoat through PS, and I thought it was him."

"feel?"

"No, it's him."

Guo Xiaotian asked: "You and the defendant passed by mistake, and the testimony said that the distance was only about one meter. You were on the shoulder of the road, and he was riding a tricycle under the shoulder of the road. May I ask, does the defendant have a hat with a raincoat on his head?"

The couple man replied: "No."

Guo Xiaotian asked: "Has his hair dyed?"

The couple man replied: "No."

Guo Xiaotian returned to the defense seat and enlarged the photo onto the projector. It was a photo of Xu's father holding a sign and wearing a prison uniform when he was arrested. His hairstyle was 37 and the part of the seven had a pinch of white dyed hair. Guo Xiaotian said: "The photo the police identified for the witness was taken by the defendant half a year ago. The defendant's hair was dyed when he was cut a hair a week before the incident. In other words, what the witness saw was not the defendant."

Sima Luo took a microphone and said, "Lawyer Guo, how do you know that the defendant's hair was dyed a week before the incident?"

Guo Xiaotian: "The information given to me by the court, please watch the video for everyone."

Short video, shooting a barber shop, the owner explained that Xu's father dyed his hair. After that, Guo Xiaotian said: "It was eleven o'clock on the day of the incident. The defendant went to the fish market to get goods at 3 o'clock in the morning and went back to open the morning market. Even if there was no video description, Xu's father had no time to dye his hair."

Sima Luo said: "On a rainy day, I didn't wear a raincoat and hat, and my hair was stuck together. The white hair was not large in area, and black hair could easily cover the white hair. In addition, everyone sees that the witness was on the left at the time. The witness said in the testimony that the defendant turned around. According to the simulation at that time, it was impossible for the defendant to turn his entire head. Half of his head, most of his side face. As expected, part of the hair on his side face was black. The question raised by Lawyer Guo was completely untenable."

Guo Xiaotian said: "Prosecutor Sima, don't ignore the key points. The police are suspicious of inducing recognition. According to psychology, a young man who meets one time or is in a relationship looks at others, and the chance of recognizing the next day is almost zero. This is an investigation report conducted by an American university. One hundred young men in love pass by a stranger. The stranger turned around and called their names. The couple looked back and looked back at the stranger. The next day, the couple was asked to select strangers from twenty photos. Only two groups of couples chose the right one and admitted that they were guessing."

"American University Report?" Sima Luo asked mockingly: "Do you believe it too?"

Judge No. 1 said: "We commissioned a special research and investigation by a university in the United States. This is the specific content of the report."

After the judge finished speaking, the waiter took out a stack of folders and sent a copy to the defense seat, the prosecution seat and the jury, and even sent a copy to the hearing.

Cao Yun looked at it a few times and knew that the material was true. Because the school was a famous school, it had a clear signature on it. After checking the authenticity, it could not be perjury. Otherwise, Lieyan Court would have made a statement. It was Guo Xiaotian who was defending it, but in fact it was Lieyan Court who used various resources to collect information to defend Xu's father.

Sima Luo looked at it for a while, closed the information and frowned.

Guo Xiaotian smiled satisfied and said, "This proves that the witness's testimony is not credible."

When Cao Yun heard this, he raised his hand and everyone paused for a while, as if the judge was also whispering something. Judge No. 1: "Lawyer Cao, the listener has no right to speak. However, because Lawyer Cao's ability is obvious to all, you can give you a chance."

The waiter sent the microphone and Cao Yun asked: "How many experimental reports did Lieyan Court make in total on couple's testimony? The background of this report is on campus and people are coming and going during the day. Based on my understanding of the court, I believe there are experimental reports that simulate the on-site situation at that time. I purely believe that there may be, and maybe not. I think if there is, it should be displayed for reference by the jury."

A few seconds later, Judge No. 1 replied: "No, there is no time, there is only this test report."

Cao Yun: "Sorry."

After Sima Luo was awakened, he immediately chased after: "This report is of no value. As Lawyer Cao said, the environment at that time was completely inconsistent with the test report. There is another detail. The defendant was driving a tricycle with a relatively high noise. Although the speed was not fast, it crushed the pool and water splashed on the ladies of the couple's trousers, which made the couple very angry. When the defendant heard the couple's roar, he looked back and did not stop or apologize, which would leave a deeper impression on the couple."

Guo Xiaotian did not refute. Xu Na in the defense seat suddenly took Mai and asked angrily: "Lawyer Cao, just forget it if you don't help my father defend, why do you still harm him?"

Cao Yun sighed: "I don't plan to harm anyone. I just hope the trial will be fair. If you think I'm harming your father, then I won't listen. I'm sorry."

Cao Yungang stood up and Judge No. 2 said: "Lawyer Cao, you leave the seat now. Any evidence that is favorable to the defendant will be suspected of being falsified. It is better to stay as supervision to supervise this trial."

Shangguan Wen said a few words in Xu Na's ear, and Xu Na said reluctantly: "I'm sorry, Lawyer Cao, I'm too excited to say the wrong thing. Please stay."

Cao Yun took a seat with an optional gesture.

It's amazing, what's the origin of this No. 2 judge? He can see through his own thoughts immediately and think of the consequences.

Cao Yun questioned the evidence, which made a lot of sense, but was kicked out of court by the defendant's daughter. In this way, the fairness of the trial was greatly reduced. Judge No. 2 did not retreat but advanced, retained Cao Yun, and gave the right to supervise, which was a very extra point act.

After everyone was quiet, Guo Xiaotian said: "The witness's testimony is still doubtful, and the police's photos have played a somewhat misleading role. The witness just explained that he and his girlfriend did not draw a conclusion when they looked at the defendant's face. The police put a raincoat to ask the witness to draw a conclusion. The credibility of the witness's testimony is questionable. I strongly recommend that the jury and the judge list the witness's testimony as reference evidence, not as evidence to judge whether the defendant is guilty."

A young lawyer raised his hand at the hearing table, because Cao Yun and the trial mode changed. The young lawyer took the microphone and said, "I agree with Lawyer Guo's statement. The witness may have been misled."

The three judges interspered and said a few words to each other, and Judge No. 1 said, "Please raise your hands if you agree with Lawyer Guo." They whispered, and they cursed in their hearts. Do you understand what the trial means? But since I give Cao Yun a back door, it is unreasonable not to give others a back door. Cao Yun is different, and Cao Yun actually helped Sima Luo refute Guo Xiaotian.

This does not prove that Sima Luo has lost his level, because this evidence was temporarily put forward.

There were seven people hearing the trial, and six people raised their hands. Judge No. 1 said: "Please move other lawyers except Lawyer Cao to the jury table. Since you like it, then be a jury."

The six people looked at each other, the guard had drawn his gun at a lawyer, and the lawyer immediately realized that he was in the Flame Court, not the real court, so he immediately moved to the jury table, and the others left the table one after another. The jurors reached seventeen.

Judge No. 2 said: "Lawyer Cao put forward his opinions, and their opinions influenced the final judgment. If any of you can make similar opinions, we are welcome. If you only be sensational and cheating, don't blame us for being rude. Do you agree? Who can you agree on behalf of? If you can only agree on behalf of yourself, don't waste everyone's time. Continue to the court."

Guo Xiaotian discussed with Shangguan Wen for a few words, and Shangguan Wen stood up: "Please ask for the second witness of this case, the owner of the convenience store across the street of Wangjia Yu Tang appeared in court."
Chapter completed!